Journal of Management Research and Analysis

Print ISSN: 2394-2762

Online ISSN: 2394-2770

CODEN : JMRABX

Journal of Management Research and Analysis (JMRA) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2014 and is published under auspices of the Innovative Education and Scientific Research Foundation (IESRF), aim to uplift researchers, scholars, academicians, and professionals in all academic and scientific disciplines. IESRF is dedicated to the transfer of technology and research by publishing scientific journals, research content, providing professional’s membership, and conducting conferences, seminars, and award programs. With more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 233

PDF Downloaded: 48


Get Permission Mathur, Agarwal, and Saxena: Unpacking the stress-satisfaction-Performance triangle in the IT workforce


Introduction

The Information Technology (IT) sector has become a critical component of modern business operations, driving innovation, connectivity, and efficiency in today's digital world. As the IT industry continues to evolve and grow, employees in this sector face unique challenges that can impact their well-being and work outcomes. Among these challenges, job stress emerges as a significant concern, given the fast-paced and demanding nature of IT roles. 1 At the same time, job satisfaction and job performance play pivotal roles in determining employees' productivity, retention, and overall success within organizations. 2, 3

Understanding the dynamic relationships among job stress, job satisfaction, team effectiveness, and job performance is essential for addressing the workforce's needs and optimizing organizational outcomes in the IT sector. Previous studies have independently explored some of these factors, but there is a need to comprehensively investigate their interconnectedness to gain a holistic understanding of how they influence each other within the IT industry.

Job stress in the IT sector can arise from factors such as tight project deadlines, high expectations, and the rapidly changing technological landscape. Understanding the sources and consequences of job stress is crucial for designing targeted interventions to support employees' mental health and mitigate burnout.

In addition, Job satisfaction is a crucial determinant of employee motivation, engagement, and retention. In the IT sector, where skilled professionals are in high demand, understanding the factors that contribute to job satisfaction can help organizations attract and retain top talent.

Moreover, Job performance directly impacts organizational productivity and competitiveness. 4 Understanding the factors that influence job performance in the IT sector can guide the implementation of measures to enhance individual and team contributions to organizational success.

Therefore, the present research aims to examine the intricate interplay of job stress, job satisfaction and job performance among IT sector employees. By investigating these factors collectively, we can gain insights into how they mutually impact each other and influence overall employee well-being and organizational performance in the IT context.

Materials and Methods

The present study was conducted from September 2022 to May 2023 in the Northern region of India. Total number of 255 IT (informational technology) professionals working in service-based multinational company from various roles and experiencelevels were recruited from the same organization to maintain the homogeneity of samples. We included the people working in the IT sector (age group: 30 to 45 years) willing to participate in the study. The participants on probation and notice period were excluded. To explore the interrelationships between job stress, job satisfaction, and job performance, a cross-sectional survey design was employed. The institute ethics committee permission was obtained for conducting the study. Informed consent (written) was obtained from the participants. The study collected data through validated questionnaires distributed among a representative sample of IT sector employees from service oriented large-scale organizations. The questionnaire included validated scales to assess job stress, job satisfaction, and job performance respectively. 5, 6, 7

Statistical analysis

Data obtained from filled questionnaire was collected manually, tabulated in MS windows excel sheet. Mean score values of the study group variables were calculated by taking sum of score of each variable (present in the above-mentioned questionnaire) of all the participant divided by number of participants. Data were analysed using SPSS 25 version using various statistical tests like t test, Pearson correlation and regression analyses to examine the associations and difference between the variables.

Results

Demographic and work profile of IT employee are represented in Table 1. The study aimed to examine the interplay of job stress, job satisfaction, team effectiveness, and job performance among IT sector employees. A cross-sectional survey was conducted, and data were collected through self-report questionnaires from a representative sample of IT professionals. The perceived stress among the employee was almost positive with more than 5 score. The stress severity was highest for moderate stress, followed by mild and then severe stress (Figure 1).

Table 1

Represents the demographic and work (Profile) characteristics of IT employee under this study (N=255)

Variables

Frequency

N %

Sex

Male

134

52.54%

Female

121

47.45%

Marital status

Married

46

18.0%

Unmarried

209

82.0%

Family type

Nuclear

188

73.7%

Joint

67

26.3%

Job type

Developer/coder

197

77.3%

Tester

18

7.1%

Documentations

22

8.6%

Tech.Com

8

3.1%

Leader

10

3.9%

Other

0

0.0%

Organizational hierarchy

Junior level

165

64.7%

Middle level

90

35.3%

Satisfied with your job

Yes

105

41.17%

No

150

58.82%

Salary (Monthly)

less than 20

37

14.5%

25-50

102

40.0%

50-1 lac

102

40.0%

above 1 Lac

14

5.5%

Which of the following is most difficult task

Work -Personal life balance

119

46.7%

Travelling

68

26.7%

Difficulty in communicating with supervisor

62

24.3%

Work related

6

2.4%

Do you attend any Work integrated continual learning

Yes

165

64.7%

No

90

35.3%

Do you wish to switch your current job role

Yes

212

45.0%

No

41

16.2%

Do you wish to switch your work mode to

Yes

115

46.7%

No

62

24.3%

Hybrid

78

30.5%

What is your main concern in the present situation

Salary

230

90.18%

Low Increment

33

13.2%

downsizing

28

11.2%

Promotion

47

18.8%

Organizational environment

35

14.0%

Figure 1

; Concerns of employee in percentage

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/1b3b891c-8b17-4424-a7cd-4a77eb5ff8e1image1.png

The stress severity was highest for moderate stress, followed my Mild, Severe and Very severe. Mean score of various variables are represented in Table 2. The satisfaction of the job among the participants were found to be Low (58%) only 42% people were satisfied with their job. Among sub variables of role based performance least mean scores were from domains of career, job and organization (Table 2).

Figure 2

Stress status in IT sector employees

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/1b3b891c-8b17-4424-a7cd-4a77eb5ff8e1image2.png
Table 2

Mean score of different study variables

Variables

Mean

Std. Deviation

Age

32.2

6.24

JSS

37.8

8.281

Stress score

21.72

5.919

RBPS (Role based performance score)

73.5

9.246

Career

11.16

2.044

Job

11.68

2.215

Innovation

14.56

2.785

Organization

11.35

2.029

Team

13.47

2.381

There were no association found between age and work variable like job satisfaction, stress and role-based performance. Job satisfaction was found to be negatively correlated with stress and positively correlated with performance (r = -0.378, p= 0.0001; RBPS r = 0.158 p=0.01). RBPS was associative with stress negatively (-0.128, p=.041).

Simple linear regression was used to test if [Job satisfaction] significantly predicted [Job performance]. The fitted regression model was: [fitted regression equation]. The overall regression was statistically significant (R2 = [0.220], F(df regression1 df residual 1) = [F-6.587], p = [0.01]).It was found that [Job satisfaction] significantly predicted [Job performance] (β = [β-0.159], p = [p-0.0001]).Various studies are similar to the findings of present study.

The work-related variable differs statistically in terms of stress, job satisfaction and performance. Stress was highest in leaders, least people working in documentation. Concern in present were Salary, low increment, downsizing, promotion and Organizational environment (Table 1). The major concern of the employees was alarmingly very high where more than 70 percent of employee shown concerns about salary issue, downsizing, poor communication with seniors followed by inflexible working hours, promotions issues and work pressure (Figure 1). Least concern was about organizational climate although it was also a significantly a big percentage of nearly 40 %.

Discussion

The findings of this study provide valuable insights into the complex relationships among job stress, job satisfaction, team effectiveness, and job performance in the IT sector. The negative correlation between job stress and job satisfaction aligns with previous research indicating that high job stress can lead to reduced employee satisfaction and overall well-being. 8, 9 Organizations in the IT sector should focus on addressing stressors and providing supportive work environments to promote employee job satisfaction and retention.

The stress was positive for all the employees. The stress severity was highest for moderate stress, followed by mild and then severe stress (Figure 1).

  1. Stress and Job Satisfaction: The results revealed a significant negative correlation between job stress and job satisfaction. This finding suggests that higher levels of job stress were associated with lower levels of job satisfaction among IT sector employees.

  2. Stress and Job Performance: The study found a significant negative correlation between job stress and job performance. This suggests that higher job stress levels were associated with decreased job performance among IT sector employees.

  3. Job Satisfaction and Job Performance: There was a significant positive correlation between job satisfaction and job performance. This indicates that higher levels of job satisfaction were associated with better job performance among IT sector employees.

The negative correlation between Stress job stress and job performance highlights the adverse effects of job stress on individual employee performance in the IT sector. Excessive stress can impair concentration, creativity, and problem-solving abilities, leading to decreased job performance.10, 11 Organizations should implement stress management programs and offer resources to help employees cope with job-related pressures effectively.

On the other hand, the positive correlations between job satisfaction, and job performance underscore the importance of employee satisfaction and team dynamics for overall work performance in the IT sector. Further there were no difference in the stress score based on gender. which suggest that stress can be present among all the employees irrespective of their biological variations.3, 12

Regression analysis shown that job satisfaction can be used to predict the performance of the employees. Satisfied employees tend to be more engaged, motivated, and collaborative, contributing to improved team effectiveness and job performance.4, 13 The score were although invariable low in subdomain of performance viz career, job and organization which was less compare to mean score of the original study (APA PsycNet, n.d.). Organizations should invest in employee satisfaction initiatives and team-building strategies to foster a positive work environment and maximize organizational outcomes.

The norm of job satisfaction given by Specter et al. (Mean score 140.7) for private sector service employee.5 In our present study none of the employee’s scores reach that mean scores which suggest poor job satisfaction mong IT sector employees. Overall, the results suggest that promoting job satisfaction, while reducing job stress can have a positive impact on job performance among IT sector employees.14, 15 Organizations can benefit from adopting comprehensive strategies that prioritize employee well-being, team collaboration, and job satisfaction, ultimately leading to a more efficient and successful IT workforce.16

The work-related variable did not differ in terms of stress, job satisfaction and performance. Similar to the study conducted by Susanto et al., our study suggest stress was highest in leaders, least people working in documentation.3 Concern in present were Salary, supervisors support, increment, downsizing, promotion and Organizational environment. These factors might be contributing to high stress and low job satisfaction and performance in our study group as it can be seen from both the figures (1&2) all the concerns are in significant no almost every variable crossed 60 percent of the respective concerns. Our findings results matches various studies which suggest all work related variables will be impacted by individual and organizational factors.3, 17

However, as a cross-sectional study, this research only captures a snapshot of the relationships among these variables. Future longitudinal studies could provide further insights into the causal relationships and changes over time, guiding the development of targeted interventions and sustainable practices to enhance employee well-being and organizational success in the IT sector.

Conclusion

The findings of this research will contribute valuable insights to both academia and the IT industry. By uncovering the complex interactions among job stress, job satisfaction, team effectiveness, and job performance, organizations can develop evidence-based strategies to promote employee well-being, job satisfaction, and overall productivity in the IT sector. Ultimately, this research aims to inform HR practices and organizational policies that optimize the performance and satisfaction of IT sector employees, leading to enhanced organizational success and a competitive edge in the digital landscape. Furthermore, the implications of this research are significant for both administrators, academicians, and researchers in the field of organizational psychology and human resource management.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

There is no conflict of interests. All authors are equally contributed.

Acknowledgment

We are thankful to all the IT employees for their co-operation and active participation in the study

References

1 

KA Park KA Johnson Job Satisfaction, Work Engagement, and Turnover Intention of CTE Health Science Teachers. Int J Res Voc Educ Train20196322442

2 

IK Aryanta NW Sitiari P Yasa Influence of Motivation on Job Stress, Job Satisfaction and Job Performance at Alam Puri Villa Art Museum and Resort DenpasarJ Ekonomi Bisnis JAGADITHA20192113120

3 

P Susanto ME Hoque T Jannat EB Zona MA Islam Work-Life Balance, Job Satisfaction, and Job Performance of SMEs Employees: The Moderating Role of Family-Supportive Supervisor BehaviorsFront Psychol202213906876

4 

JY Lee S Yoo Y Lee S Park SW Yoon Individual and organisational factors affecting knowledge workers’ perceptions of the effectiveness of informal learning: A multilevel analysis. Vocat Learning201912115577

5 

S Cohen T Kamarck R Mermelstein Perceived stress scale. Measuring Stress: A Guide for Health and Social Scientists199412

6 

PE Spector The Job Satisfaction Survey (JSS)Am J Commun Psychol198513216572

7 

TM Welbourne DE Johnson A Erez The Role-Based Performance Scale: Validity analysis of a theory-based measureAcad Manag J199841554055

8 

TC Dodanwala DS Santoso V Yukongdi Examining work role stressors, job satisfaction, job stress, and turnover intention of Sri Lanka’s construction industry. Int J Construc Manag20222315110

9 

AW Ling A Bahron P Boroh A study on role stress and job satisfaction among bank employees in Kota KinabaluInt J Res Manag Business Stud20143431923

10 

A Basit Z Hassan Impact of job stress on employee performanceInt J Account Business Manag201721333

11 

W Si NA Khan M Ali MW Amin Q Pan Excessive enterprise social media usage and employee creativity: An application of the transactional theory of stress and copingActa Psychologica2023232103811

12 

BJ Babin JS Boles The effects of perceived co-worker involvement and supervisor support on service provider role stress, performance and job satisfactionJ Retailing19967215775

13 

C Mafini N Dlodlo The linkage between work-related factors, employee satisfaction and organisational commitment: Insights from public health professionalsSA J Hum Resou Manag201412115

14 

A Raziq R Maulabakhsh Impact of working environment on job satisfaction. Procedia Econ Fin20152371725

15 

UA Warraich R Ahmed N Ahmad I Khoso Impact of stress on job performance: An empirical study of the employees of private sector universities of KarachiPaki R J Manag Sci201437147

16 

D Bakotić Relationship between job satisfaction and organisational performanceEcon Res Ekonomska Istraživanja 20162911830

17 

E Kahya The effects of job characteristics and working conditions on job performanceInt J Indus Ergon200737651523



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Original Article


Article page

163-167


Authors Details

Nidhi Mathur, Nimmi Agarwal, Rahul Saxena


Article History

Received : 10-06-2024

Accepted : 03-07-2024


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files